• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
location iconSuite 503, 5/F, St. George's Building, 2 Ice House Street, Central, Hong Kongphone-icon +852 2868 0696 linkedintwitterfacebook
OLN IP Services
close-btn
OLN IP Services
Get bespoke and commercially-driven advice to your Intellectual Property
Learn More
OLN IP Services
OLN Online
close-btn
OLN Online
Powered by Oldham, Li & Nie, the law firm of choice for Hong Kong’s vibrant startup and SME community, OLN Online is a forward-looking and seamless addition to traditional legal services – a true disruptor.
Learn More
OLN IP Services
  • FR
    • ENG
    • 简
    • 繁
    • 日本語
Oldham, Li & Nie
OLN IP Services
close-btn
OLN IP Services
Get bespoke and commercially-driven advice to your Intellectual Property
Learn More
OLN IP Services
OLN Online
close-btn
OLN Online
Powered by Oldham, Li & Nie, the law firm of choice for Hong Kong’s vibrant startup and SME community, OLN Online is a forward-looking and seamless addition to traditional legal services – a true disruptor.
Learn More
OLN IP Services
  • À propos
        • Distinctions et classements
        • Responsabilité sociale des entreprises
  • Domaines de pratique
        • Canadian Notarization Services
        • China Practice
        • Droit du Travail et de l’Immigration Appliqué aux Entreprises
        • Droit des Procédures Collectives et des Restructurations
        • Droit des Dommages Corporels
        • Conseil Fiscal
        • Résolution des Litiges
        • Droit des Sociétés et Droit Commercial
        • Droit de la Famille
        • Droit des Assurances
        • Clientèle Privée
        • Pratique Japonaise
        • Fonds Offshore
        • Regulatory Compliance, Investigations and Enforcement
        • Fraude Commerciale et Recherche d'Avoirs
        • Pratique Française
        • Droit de la Propriété Intellectuelle
        • Services Financiers et Règlementations
        • Services Notariaux
        • Startups
        • Chinese Notary Services (CAAO)
        • Canadian Notarization Services
        • China Practice
        • Droit des Sociétés et Droit Commercial
        • Fraude Commerciale et Recherche d’Avoirs
        • Droit du Travail et de l’Immigration Appliqué aux Entreprises
        • Droit de la Famille
        • Pratique Française
        • Droit des Procédures Collectives et des Restructurations
        • Droit des Assurances
        • Droit de la Propriété Intellectuelle
        • Droit des Dommages Corporels
        • Clientèle Privée
        • Services Financiers et Règlementations
        • Conseil Fiscal
        • Pratique Japonaise
        • Services Notariaux
        • Résolution des Litiges
        • Fonds Offshore
        • Startups
        • Droit des Ainés
        • Regulatory Compliance, Investigations and Enforcement
        • Chinese Notary Services (CAAO)
  • Notre equipe
  • Actualités
  • Nos bureaux

Suite 503, St. George's Building,
2 Ice House Street, Central, Hong Kong

Tel. +852 2868 0696 | Send Email
linkedin twitter facebook
OLN Blue

OLN

  • À propos d’ OLN
    • CSR
    • Distinctions & Classements
  • Awards and Ranking
  • Block Content Examples
  • Carrières
  • Ce que les autres disent
  • Client Information & Registration
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie Policy (EU)
  • Globalaw
  • La responsabilité sociale des entreprises au sein d’OLN
  • Le cabinet
  • Nos services
  • Notre equipe
  • Oldham, Li & Nie
  • OLN Podcasts
  • Our Offices
  • Privacy Policy
  • Review
  • Reviews
  • Standard Terms of Engagement
  • Test Blog
  • À propos
        • Distinctions et classements
        • Responsabilité sociale des entreprises
  • Domaines de pratique
        • Canadian Notarization Services
        • China Practice
        • Droit du Travail et de l’Immigration Appliqué aux Entreprises
        • Droit des Procédures Collectives et des Restructurations
        • Droit des Dommages Corporels
        • Conseil Fiscal
        • Résolution des Litiges
        • Droit des Sociétés et Droit Commercial
        • Droit de la Famille
        • Droit des Assurances
        • Clientèle Privée
        • Pratique Japonaise
        • Fonds Offshore
        • Regulatory Compliance, Investigations and Enforcement
        • Fraude Commerciale et Recherche d'Avoirs
        • Pratique Française
        • Droit de la Propriété Intellectuelle
        • Services Financiers et Règlementations
        • Services Notariaux
        • Startups
        • Chinese Notary Services (CAAO)
        • Canadian Notarization Services
        • China Practice
        • Droit des Sociétés et Droit Commercial
        • Fraude Commerciale et Recherche d’Avoirs
        • Droit du Travail et de l’Immigration Appliqué aux Entreprises
        • Droit de la Famille
        • Pratique Française
        • Droit des Procédures Collectives et des Restructurations
        • Droit des Assurances
        • Droit de la Propriété Intellectuelle
        • Droit des Dommages Corporels
        • Clientèle Privée
        • Services Financiers et Règlementations
        • Conseil Fiscal
        • Pratique Japonaise
        • Services Notariaux
        • Résolution des Litiges
        • Fonds Offshore
        • Startups
        • Droit des Ainés
        • Regulatory Compliance, Investigations and Enforcement
        • Chinese Notary Services (CAAO)
  • Notre equipe
  • Actualités
  • Nos bureaux
Hu Yangyong v Alba Asia Limited, Employment dispute, wrongful dismissal Hong Kong

Court of First Instance ruled employer failed to justify summary dismissal and awarded damages of more than HKD5.4 million to employee

Employment Dispute

Court of First Instance ruled employer failed to justify summary dismissal and awarded damages of more than HKD5.4 million to employee

juillet 17, 2025 by OLN Marketing

In Hu Yangyong v Alba Asia Limited [2025] HKCFI 2484 (OLN acted for the Plaintiff), the Court of First Instance found that the Defendant employer company failed to discharge its burden of justifying summary dismissal, and the Plaintiff employee was wrongfully dismissed by the Defendant employer company. The Court awarded damages to the Plaintiff as a result of the wrongful dismissal.

The Plaintiff was the Chief Operating Officer (Asia) of the Defendant since 1 June 2017. The Plaintiff’s employment contract provided for various allowances and benefits, such as out-of-pocket family expense reimbursement and business expense reimbursement. On 7 September 2018, the Plaintiff was summarily dismissed by the Defendant on the grounds of alleged misconduct and dishonesty arising from reimbursement of expenses.

The Court of First Instance reiterated and reaffirmed the principle on summary dismissal:
Summary dismissal is regarded as a strong and extreme measure and is justified only in exceptional cases. The onus of proof is on the employer to establish that summary dismissal is justified. The standard of proof is generally the balance of probabilities, but the more serious the allegation, the stronger the evidence must be before the court concludes that the allegation is proven. While summary dismissal may be justified by an act of gross misconduct by the employee, what amounts to gross misconduct requires a fact-finding exercise. An act of dishonesty will not automatically justify summary dismissal since there are degrees of dishonesty. Summary dismissal will only be justified if the dishonest act amounts to a repudiation of the contract of employment.

In the present case, the Court of First Instance found, amongst others, that summary dismissal was not justified, as the Defendant had failed to meet the thresholds required for summary dismissal. In particular, the Court found that the Plaintiff had genuinely incurred family expenses exceeding the threshold and had nothing to gain personally. The Defendant failed to show that the Plaintiff had acted with dishonesty or fraudulent intent.

Key takeaways:

Summary dismissal should be considered as a remedy of last resort. Employers should exercise caution before making a decision to summarily dismiss an employee.

The full judgment can be viewed here:

[https://legalref.judiciary.hk/lrs/common/search/search_result_detail_frame.jsp?DIS=169764&QS=%24%28alba%2Casia%29&TP=JU]

Partner Victor Ng, Senior Associate Barbara Kwong, and Associate Claudia Wong acted for the Plaintiff.

OLN has extensive experience in handling employment-related matters, including wrongful termination, and contractual disputes. With a strong track record of representing both employers and employees, OLN is well-equipped to provide practical, strategic, and effective legal advice to navigate complex employment issues.

Disclaimer: This article is for reference only. Nothing herein shall be construed as Hong Kong legal advice or any legal advice for that matter to any person. Oldham, Li & Nie shall not be held liable for any loss and/or damage incurred by any person acting as a result of the materials contained in this article.

Filed Under: Droit du Travail et de l’immigration Appliqué aux Entreprises Tagged With: Employment Dispute

Primary Sidebar

This website uses cookies to optimise your experience and to collect information to customise content. By closing this banner, clicking a link or continuing to browse otherwise, you agree to the use of cookies. Please read the cookies section of our Privacy Policy to learn more. Learn more

Footer

OLN logo

Suite 503, 5/F, St George's Building
2 Ice House Street, Central
Hong Kong

Tel. +852 2868 0696 | Email us
À propos Notre equipe Nos bureaux OLN IP Services Politique de confidentialité
Domaines de pratique Actualités Carrières OLN Online
À propos Practice Areas Notre equipe Actualités Nos bureaux
Carrières OLN IP Services OLN Online Politique de confidentialité
linkedin twitter facebook
OLN logo

© 2025 Oldham, Li & Nie. All Rights Reserved.

Manage Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}
Contactez-nous

Veuillez partager les détails de votre message ici. Nous vous contacterons sous peu.

    x